Okay I want to premise this by saying that there are probably bomb analysis and theory videos out there that do a better job than I could ever dream of doing, but this is for me.
{Spoilers}
It's been a while since I've watched such a heart wrenching anime. Sure every now and then I'll go on a tangent about how relatable an anime was because a lot of the times yeah there's relatable content, but this is just on a whole other level. Honestly I've been hyped about this being released as an anime since that first OST came out. You know the one that everyone, and I mean everyone, made covers of? Yeah that one. I've been hyped since then and that was years ago. The only thing stopping me from watching it was school and the fact that I wanted to binge it all. And let me tell you that my heart was not ready. This review is going to be all over the place and I don't really care.
Can we first just start off with how beautiful everything was? Kyoani really outdid themselves. All of the textures that you could just feel through the screen with those rich colors and just everything about it really. It was all so fluid and with everything you could just see how beautiful everything in this world is in contrast to the nastiness of war.
I'm not really into war films all that much. I think that the only thing war really brings out is a lot of technology, useless or not you decide, and a lot of suffering. I think Violet Evergarden really showcased part of what it's like living through war and having to build everything up after that. I don't know if it's just me, but I feel like in history class they focus a lot on the wars and all of the political stuff, the really macro view of everything, so much so that we kind of get desensitized to how devastating war is. Take for example the post office that Hodgins sets up. The reason he set that whole company up was because a lot of people still couldn't write but they needed some form of communication. One problem I kind of have with this whole postal communication thing is that they had advanced enough medicine to give Violet two prosthetic arms, but they didn't have anything else particularly advanced in the same way. Maybe my idea of medicine in the time period they are trying to portray is a bit remedial, but it just amazes me that they could build such advanced prosthetics, but still not be able to have a whole lot of other advances at the same time.
But continuing on with the building back of society after the war. Besides all of the infrastructure that everyone's working on like the transcontinental railroad to unite the northern and southern regions and everything everyone's doing in order to bring everything back to the status quo of business as usual, trying to recover from the war, you also see how broken everyone is. Everyone is touched in some way or the other by the war. Some of them have lost people they know, loved ones, or they've lost their homes or people just treat them differently. Like Hodgins said to Violet, everyone's burning. It's just so sad how terribly war strikes and even when it's over its impacts don't subside for a long time. Everyone is still left with the void left by things the war took from them.
And from all of this loss from the war come many different people. There are people that lost everything in the war and seek revenge, like the anti-peace factions. They lost everything and because of that they just wanted everyone else to suffer. And honestly since they went through all of that hardship, it's hard to blame them. Their lives must've looked so incredibly bleak. Same to the people who lost their family members in the war. At the beginning of the series I despised Dietfried. I thought he was such an ass for "gifting" Gilbert with Violet as if she were just a tool. And afterwards he only treated her with scorn and never saw her as more than a dog. But when she protected him from the anti-peace faction and he was able to see how she was able to voice her emotions and he was able to finally see how human she really was and how much she really cared for Gilbert, seeing how he started to let go of his resentment for her was cathartic. It's really easy to pawn off the blame on someone else in order to cope with unwanted emotions, which was what Dietfried did for so long, but he was able to find it in his heart to see Violet as someone who loved Gilbert just as much as he did, as an equal instead of a lesser war dog. I think these transformations from how the war twisted people and how they overcame all the burns that the war left them with is a beautiful thing. Especially for the main protagonist Violet.
I'm sure a lot of people have already analyzed her and come up with most of the symbolic things that make Violet such an interesting person, but bear with me here. In the beginning of the show she was extremely militant. When there's flashbacks of when Dietfried originally gave her to Gilbert she was seen as almost a rabid animal that was supposed to be used for as long as it was useful and then thrown away. Obviously Gilbert saw her as more than that, but as it was her personality wasn't allowed to grow into anything more than an unfeeling war machine. This is symbolically shown consistently throughout the show with her biting the maids hand when Gilbert first brought her to his home and later on when she first took off the gloves that covered her hands with her teeth. This animalistic and wild nature of hers starts to diminish as the series goes on and she's able to start experiencing lots of different human emotions on her assignments as an auto memory doll. Her lack of knowledge about regular humans is also captured in the fact that her arms are made of metal. That paired with her originally placid expression give off the feeling of an inhuman android. However, though her arms make her different from the average person, they're also the symbol of the ultimate sacrifice. Because of her upbringing to be more of a war tool and less of a person she didn't have the capacity, whether we're talking about verbalization or even mental preparation, to have feelings for another human being. If she was taught anything along the lines of sympathy and mercy it wouldn't have been possible for her to kill anyone. Instead she was taught to be cold and unfeeling. And despite that constant demeanor of an unfeeling tool lies the innate nature that humans have within them to protect the ones she love. When Gilbert was dying on the stairs of the base and her arm just came off and she tried to drag him with her teeth I was close to tears. She didn't even know what the phrase "I love you" meant, but she was so wholeheartedly devoted to Gilbert that she never gave up on trying to save him. She was in so much excruciating pain, but her love for him overcame that. He was the first person to ever show her kindness and treat her as more than just a tool. He was the first person she probably ever loved. The devotion she had for him and their whole relationship, while strained and broken due to the premise of the war, was so utterly compelling.
And while at first Violet was unable to understand what the phrase "I love you" meant, she sought out the meaning of it as an auto memory doll and was able to understand human emotions through it. I felt personally that the episodes were a little rushed. If it was even 15 episodes I think a lot of other things could be explained such as where Dietfried found her, or give us a better flow than just a new letter writing request every time. While it lent itself for a quick paced show that always kept me engaged, I wouldn't have minded more time in each place to get to know people more and to see a more drawn out evolution of Violet. I understand that this was probably more of the highlights of how each letter changed Violet in some way and opened up her emotional capacity to feel, however at the same time I also feel as if something is missing. Like in episode 5 all of a sudden Dietfried comes out of nowhere and goes "how could you write letter that bring people together when you've murdered so many people?" and while yeah that's true, it was also a little out of left field. It's things like that which kind of caught me off guard and left me desiring a little bit more at times. But back to the main thought (I pretend like this is organized, but mostly this is just a rant lol).
Throughout all of Violet's letter writing assignments she's able to experience different faucets of the human experience that she missed out on as she was trained to just kill people. She learned many things such as the delicate nature of words and how to read people's actions, words and emotions as well as the beauty of the bonds in between people and the different kinds of love that they share. Throughout a lot of these letter writings, V and I both felt extremely moved to the point of tears. I think it just depends on what kind of person you and and your own personal experiences, but just a lot of parts moved me to tears. Especially episode 10. There's just something really personal that happened to me that makes me really sad when I think about people losing their parents. It's probably because I'm so close to my parents that I feel this way, but just the whole thing of even when their parent is gone, that they're still looking out for them is so indescribably sweet. Oh my god I'm tearing up right now thinking about that episode. There's just a lot of scenes in Violet Evergarden that I don't think can be fully experience through words. It can only be evoked through sight, the motion and facial expressions these people make. And it's things like this that really get to Violet and in some ways educate her in all the ways humans are so complex. Another episode that got to me was episode 5. I'm a sucker for a good romance story as you could probably already tell. There was just something about this, although thinking about it right now is kind of disturbing thinking about a 14 year old girl marrying a guy that's 10 years older, that's so endearing. Like the love letters they send each other at first are so flowery and poetic, and utterly fake, and then with Violet and Cattleya's intervention they start sending letters to each other that are so real. And the kingdom reading them also starts to get super invested in the letters and relates to them a lot more when they're written by real people instead of by a Doll. It's something so small, but at the same time it's so sweet thinking about that sort of thing. Like how neither of them were perfect, but they were happy together.
There are a million little subtleties that I could've brought up if I had just jotted them down when I had the idea, but I like the idea of writing things organically anyways rather than having it be very structured like a regular school essay. I've done enough of those to know that they get the point across better and you don't necessarily need to have a certain feeling in order to write them, blog posts are different in that you want them to be organized, but I'd rather have the feeling be there rather than it be necessarily easy to read. But maybe that's just me. I guess if I have any more subtleties I'd like to add on I could just add a postscript with the day I add upon this.
Overall I'd say that this was an amazing watch. I don't know if it was so impressive because I just love Kyoani so much, or because I have a secret love for historical fiction, or because I love people overcoming struggles in times of difficulty, or I just love watching humans fight for humanity, or I just haven't watched an anime with a plot in a while. Maybe it's a combination of all of these things. Maybe it's how it makes my soul feel. It makes me feel happy and fulfilled and full and satisfied and warm when I see those warm market lights with Gilbert buying Violet the brooch that looks like his eyes or seeing those scenery shots or the OP or the ED or just all of it as a whole. Heck I might even rewatch it it was so good and I never rewatch things. It was just so amazing and I think the next project was introduced at the last episode? I could be wrong. But I'm here for it if it does happen. I pray for better pacing though. Other than that it was so incredibly beautiful. I was plunged into that world. I became more heartfelt and emotionally awakened alongside Violet. I have nothing but endless good things to say.
Also you can stop scrolling now because I watched the series on Netflix and it doesn't let you take screenshots. Haha sorry I just really like good quality and since I've got a Netflix account, why not take advantage of it right? Anyways y'all probably already know how beautiful it is smh so many people make gif sets of it.